A Crisis of Leadership: The Mismanagement of the BBVOA

The tenure of Chris Cheeley as President of the Black Bay Village Owners Association (BBVOA) stands as a masterclass in mismanagement, self-interest, and a blatant disregard for community welfare. Rather than serving as a steward for the neighborhood, his leadership has systematically eroded trust, replacing functional governance with a regime centered entirely on personal advantage.

At the heart of this dysfunction is a glaring conflict of interest: Mr. Cheeley has never actually resided within the BBVOA community. His relationship with the neighborhood appears purely transactional rather than communal. Having developed the community's final 24 homes, he strategically retained ownership of a dozen properties to operate strictly as rentals. This maneuver was not merely an investment strategy; it effectively weaponized his ownership into a disproportionate, insurmountable voting bloc. By leveraging these proxy votes, he has successfully monopolized control of the HOA, subjugating the needs, property values, and voices of actual resident-owners to his own financial gain.

Furthermore, his administration operates behind an impenetrable wall of secrecy, defined by a complete absence of transparency. In a staggering display of arrogance, Mr. Cheeley actively conceals his direct contact information, deliberately withholding his phone number and email address from the very people he is obligated to represent. This calculated evasion of accountability is designed to silence homeowner concerns, suppress legitimate dissent, and ensure his decisions go unquestioned.

By flatly refusing to engage in even the most basic communication with association members, he has abandoned the fundamental fiduciary and ethical duties of his office. He has proven himself to be a profoundly ineffective and damaging HOA President—one whose continued control remains a direct and ongoing detriment to the entire community.